Finding the right toys for your dog is more than just picking something off the shelf. The right toy supports your dog’s health, behavior, and overall happiness. With so many types of dog toys—chew toys, plush toys, squeaky toys, tug toys, and more—knowing what to choose can be the difference between safe, enriching play and unwanted risks.

Let’s break down how to choose the right toys, what to avoid, and how specific toys fit into a safe and fun toy routine for your furry friend.

What Types of Toys Are Safe for My Dog?

Safety comes first when choosing toys. The wrong toy can be a choking hazard or cause damage to your dog’s teeth or gums. Choose dog-proof toys—those made for dogs and tested for safety. Avoid standard tennis balls, which can wear down teeth, and toys small enough to get lodged in your dog’s throat.

Safe toy types include:

• Rubber toys: Durable and bouncy, great for fetch or solo chewing.
• Rope toys: Ideal for tug of war and chewing. Supervise to ensure strings don't unravel.
• Chew toys: Designed for dogs who love to gnaw. Helps with teething and anxiety.
• Interactive toys: Puzzle toys or treat-dispensing toys provide mental stimulation.
• Plush toys: Soft and comforting, especially for gentle dogs or for snuggling.

One safe and stimulating option for play and fetching is the Chuckit! Max Glow Ultra Fetch Stick. It's made of durable rubber and glows in the dark—perfect for low-light play and interactive fun without risking your dog’s safety.

How Do I Select the Right Size Toy for My Dog?

A toy should match the size of your dog’s mouth. Toys that are too small can be swallowed, while oversized toys may frustrate smaller breeds. Here’s how to pick by size:

• Small breeds (under 20 lbs): Look for toys labeled “small dog” or “toy breed.”
• Medium breeds (20–50 lbs): Medium-sized toys, not too light or too bulky.
• Large breeds (50+ lbs): Heavier, bigger toys that can stand up to powerful jaws.

The BarkBone Natural Instinct Peanut Butter Infused Nylon Chew Ring is ideal for medium to large dogs that enjoy long-lasting chew sessions. It’s strong enough for aggressive chewers and infused with peanut butter flavor—something many dogs like.

Check your dog’s toys weekly to make sure they’re still safe. Discard toys that are broken, torn, or missing parts.

How Can I Keep My Dog Mentally Stimulated with Toys?

Dogs need more than physical exercise—they also need to expend pent-up mental energy. Toys can help with that. Puzzle toys and interactive toys are a great way to keep your dog engaged. Mental stimulation through toys can prevent boredom and reduce problem behaviors like chewing on furniture or barking excessively. Good options include:

• Treat-dispensing puzzle toys
• Hide and seek plush creatures
• Tug toys that involve strategy
• Toys with unpredictable movements or sounds

The Chuckit! Crunch Duo Tug Dog Toy blends sound and interactivity. Its crunchy material keeps your dog’s attention, while the tug design makes it perfect for interactive play and building the bond between you and your dog.

Rotate toys regularly—bringing out “new” toys keeps things exciting and helps keep your dog busy when you're not around.

Can Toys Help with My Dog's Dental Health?

Yes—chew toys and dental chews can play a role in your dog’s oral hygiene. Some toys are designed to scrape off plaque and massage gums as your dog chews.

Toys that help with dental care usually feature:

• Textured surfaces
• Durable rubber or nylon material
• Edges that reach between teeth

These toys don't replace brushing but are a helpful addition to a healthy dental routine.

The JW Puppy Teeth-ee Set is made for teething puppies but also works for small adult dogs who need gentle gum massage and relief. The soft material is safe on sensitive gums, while the shape encourages proper chewing habits.

Always monitor your dog's chewing habits and play style. Aggressive chewers can break off chunks of softer toys—discard them immediately if this happens.

Are Plush Toys Suitable for All Dogs?

Plush toys can be a comfort item for many dogs, but not all dogs should have them. Dogs that rip toys apart or try to eat the stuffing should avoid soft stuffed toys. On the other hand, dogs that like to cuddle or carry their favorite toy around often enjoy plush creatures.

Signs your dog may enjoy plush toys:

• Carry it gently
• Sleeps with it
• Uses it for comfort

Signs to avoid plush toys:

• Destroys or eats stuffing
• Aggressive chewing behavior

For gentle chewers, the Zoobilee Fisherman Heggie Dog Toy is a soft and funny-looking plush toy that squeaks, making it a fun comfort toy for relaxed play. It's a great distraction toy for mellow dogs. Remember, check for loose parts or damaged seams, especially if your dog shows signs of chewing too hard.

Are There Specific Toys Recommended for Puppies?

Puppies have special needs, especially during the teething phase. Toys for teething puppies should be soft, flexible, and safe for small mouths. At the same time, they need to teach appropriate and inappropriate behavior, helping shape lifelong chewing habits.

Look for toys that:

• Relieve teething pain
• Fit their smaller mouths
• Are free from small parts
• Encourage gentle chewing

Soft rubber and flexible nylon toys are best.

For indoor fetch, the Chuckit! Indoor Roller Dog Toy is another smart choice for puppies. Its soft construction makes it safe for furniture and gentle puppy mouths while providing physical exercise.

It’s a good idea to supervise playtime and teach puppies not to chew on shoes or dirty laundry by giving them a better option—at least one toy available at all times can make all the difference.

Play Smarter: Selecting Toys That Truly Fit Your Dog

Choosing the right toy depends on your dog’s personality, chewing habits, play style, and size. There’s no one-size-fits-all; sometimes it takes trying a few different types to see what your dog loves. Always consider safety, durability, and your dog’s behavior when choosing.

At Petmate, we understand your dog deserves more than just any toy. That’s why we offer a premium line of safe, durable, and fun pet supplies. Explore our collection to find the perfect toy for your best friend—one that’s built for their health, happiness, and daily play.

A happy dog is an engaged dog—and the right toy makes all the difference.